Between Private Tastes and Public Influence ? Private Art Collections in Germany

Never before have there been so many private collectors making extensive acquisitions of contemporary art. Are they the real key figures of a global art business?... more more

GoetheInstitute

28/09/2006

From the Feuilletons is a weekly overview of what's been happening in the German-language cultural pages and appears every Friday at 3 pm. CET.. Here a key to the German newspapers.

Die Zeit, 28.09.2006

The situation of Muslims in Germany can only get worse, fears Navid Kermani in a pessimistic article coinciding with a conference on Islam in Germany. Worldwide attacks by fundamentalists will not let up, Kermani writes, while Islam is in an unprecedented crisis. "For example, what a catastrophic state Muslim theology is in! Take Al-Azhar University in Cairo, the major Sunni religious institution... The intellectual level of reflection at the central Sunni religious authority is probably inferior to most village parishes in Switzerland. The intellectual decrepitude of orthodox Islam – whose former vitality is astonishing – the decline of a major religious culture, is what has made fundamentalism possible. Fundamentalism is not the product of orthodoxy, it's an answer to the crisis in orthodoxy. Political Islam developed among the urban middle classes because orthodoxy could no longer provide answers."

Power is investing in art in Kiev, reports Barbara Lehmann. A banker related to President Yuschenko wants to build a Ukranian version of the Hermitage Museum, Lehmann writes, while the son-in-law of ex-president Leonid Kuchma, Victor Pinchuk, has just inaugurated his centre for contemporary art with pomp and ceremony. "We are like you!, is the message to Western visitors. Only hipper, cooler, richer. Installations, videos, paintings and photos of the most fashionable Western artists decorate the stylish rooms: Oliafur Eliasson, Philippe Pareno, Thomas Ruff, Sarah Morris."


Frankfurter Rundschau, 28.09.2006

Christian Thomas sees the cancellation of "Idomeno" in Berlin's Deutsche Oper (more here) hitting at the heart of "the Western bourgeois self-understanding since the European Enlightenment.... It's not just since the 'Idomeneo' affair in Berlin that people recognise Islamism for the terrible leveller that it is. It hangs a world-wide domestic politics of fear over the globe, creating a global spirit of intolerance. Added to this comes the knowledge that the Deutsche Oper Berlin has renounced any belief in its historical mission. Both, the belief as much as the mission, could be considered a duty that was as divine as it was profane. This duty would consist in heroically defending the stage as the birthplace not just of our civil understanding, but of Western civilisation's very understanding of itself."


Neue Zürcher Zeitung, 28.09.2006

Claudia Schwartz reveals further details about the cancellation of "Idomeneo". "The episode carries the whiff of the dilettantism typical of local politics, the order of the day in Berlin. Berlin's Interior Minister Ehrhart Körting inspired fears in the opera director Kirsten Harms following an anonymous tip from the security authorities and a non-specific 'situation of danger' registered by Berlin's Criminal Investigation Office, by saying that he drives by the West Berlin opera on a daily basis and would not want it 'to no longer be there.' Harms explains that Körting suggested two possible solutions: either change or cancel the opera. Incidentally, the minister, responsible for Berlin's security, left the decision of how to deal with the situation up to the opera director."


Süddeutsche Zeitung, 28.09.2006

The paper prints the Berlin Criminal Investigation Office' s very imaginative assessment of the risk represented by "Idomeneo": "According to an evaluation of the Federal Criminal Office, to which Islamic experts contributed, representations of the prophet Muhammed are strictly prohibited in Islam. The Neuenfels production could lead to associations with existent videos of decapitations in Iraq by Islamic militants. This could be understood as a call for the decapitation of Muhammed, on in other words, as a vitiation of Islam."


Der Tagesspiegel, 28.09.2006

In an interview with Christina Tilmann, British art critic Mark Gisbourne explains what makes Berlin so attractive for international artists. "It's too simple just to say Berlin's so attractive just because you can live here cheaply or find inexpensive studio space. You can do that in Sofia and elsewhere. It's much more the idea of the city as an open space, one which is still undefined. Berlin is something special, a city that lives from its reputation.... And this has less to do with history than with the city's spirit. Berlin is rather aggressive, it's a worker's city, quite rough. It doesn't have the pretensions of other cities, and there isn't such a dependence on lifestyle."


Die Welt, 28.09.2006


Jennifer Wilton reports that the British comedian Sacha Baron Cohen, better known as Ali G, has irritated the Kazakhstan President Nursultan Nazarbaev with his impersonation of the doltish Kazakhstani reporter Borat Sagdiyev. A 40 million dollar, state subsidised film about the Kazakhstani figher Mansur is supposed to polish up his image. "During Nazarbaev's visit in the USA this week, ads are running in American television for Kazakhstan. The President wants to bring up the 'Borat case' during his meeting with President George W. Bush. The speaker of the Kazakhstani foreign ministry, Yerzhan Ashykbaev, is quick to assure that the ads have nothing to do with the antics of the British comedian. He says it's clear that the Borat character is satirical. 'But why does Mr. Cohen have to choose Kazakhstan as his hero's homeland?'"


Frankfurter Allgemeine Zeitung, 28.09.2006

Niklas Maak visits an exhibition of Picasso's later work in the Viennese Albertina, and is especially impressed by the sketchy larger paintings. "The paint wages war against the contours. Black lines act as guard rails of the bodies, and are rolled over by dashing colours. The bodies themselves are often inextricable cubist bundles, recalling the legendary characters in Plato's "Banquet". These had two heads and four legs, and were sawed in two by Zeus as punishment. The resulting men and women then went around looking for their missing halves."

Get the signandsight newsletter for regular updates on feature articles.
signandsight.com - let's talk european.

 
More articles

From the Feuilletons

Saturday 13 - Friday 19 March, 2010

The Feuilletons this week were preoccupied by two issues: child abuse by the Catholic Church, and (again!) copy-paste abuse by the young German writer Helene Hegemann. The FAZ looks back at the days when castration was considered an acceptable method of producing angelic voices. Die Zeit looks to the narcissistic principle of similarity in a patriarchal society for an explanation. On the eve of the Leipzig Book Fair, a list of German writers, Günter Grass and Christa Wolf among them, sign a petition against plagiarism - although, as we discover, Christa Wolf might be considered a pioneer in such matters herself.
read more

From the Feuilletons

Saturday 6 - Friday 12 March, 2010

The Dutch author Hans Maarten van der Brink lists a number of contradictory reasons why his compatriots might give Geert Wilders their vote in June. Ai Weiwei defends his heavy surfing habit. Die Welt prints a reportage on the first ever critical edition of the Koran, coming to you from Potsdam. Mircea Cartarescu explains why he's too old to write poetry. And the taz and the NZZ report on reprisals against writers in Iran.
read more

From the Feuilletons

Saturday 27 February - Friday 5 March, 2010

Having been apprehended on his way to the lit.cologne, Liao Yiwu sends his German readers a song for the dongxiao. Die Welt describes Ryszard Kapuscinski as a partisan writer who was prone to self-censorship. In the NZZ, Martin Pollack explains why he won't be translating the Kapuscinski biography into German - not becuase of its truths but because of its tone. The pianist Krystian Zimerman explains the difference between volume and dynamism. The FAZ bemoans the influence of the collector in today's art market. And Gunter Grass has opened his Stasi file.
read more

From the Feuilletons

Saturday 20 - Friday 26 February, 2010

Frank Rieger of the Computer Chaos Club looks at the algorithmic structure of state surveillance. The feuilletons are all happy about "Honey" getting the Golden Bear at an otherwise lame duck of a Berlinale. Theatre director Frank Castorf explains why the poet Michael Reinhold Lenz is not Kurt Cobain. And Adam Krzeminski mourns the 'curse' of being Romanian, Polish, Latvian or Slovak.
read more

From the Feuilletons

Friday 12 - Friday 19 February, 2010

Polanski's "Ghost Writer" has brought architectural torment to the Berlinale, of the type only a good brandy can relieve. Audiences booed at Oskar Roehler's "Jew Suess - Rise and Fall", as soon as a nerve was touched. Benjamin Heisenberg provokes sympathy with the bank robber and marathon runner "Pumpgun Ronnie". In the plagiarism scandal surrounding Helene Hegemann's book "Axelotl Roadkill" the criticism is now being directed back at the critics. And Czech writer Radka Denemarkova is furious at her country for sweeping the past under the carpet.
read more

From the Feuilletons

Saturday 6 - Friday 12 February, 2010

While Berlinale director Dieter Kosslick focusses his attention on culinary cinema, Werner Herzog describes how to organise your own Berlinale. Psychiatrist and writer Ion Viona explains why post-communist Romania is built on quicksand. The feuilletons were shaken, but not really, to discover that child prodigy Helene Hegemann copied and pasted much of her celebrated novel "Axolotl Roadkill". The Tagesspiegel sets out on the trail of the clan behind the "honour killing" of Hatun Sürücü. And the SZ reports on an impressive show of solidarity at Hrant Dink's trial in Istanbul.
read more

From the Feuilletons

Saturday 30 January - Friday 5 February, 2010

The FR tells Germany to grant its immigrants suffrage. The FAZ observes Austria's desperate struggle to hold onto its remaining sovereignty. In die Welt, Zafer Senocak turns the attention of the Europeans towards the modern face of the Muslim woman. The SZ is spellbound by Maurizio Pollini, who just does everything right. An obituary to J.D. Salinger celebrates his androgynous style. And Tehran's Fajr Film Festival is haemorrhaging jurors.
read more

From the Feuilletons

Saturday 23 - Friday 29 January, 2010

Henryk Broder explains why being dubbed a "hate preacher" can feel like a compliment. Andrzej Stasiuk visits the bare patch of earth that was once a death camp in Belzec. Necla Kelek tugs at the Islamic veil. Die Welt applauds the young and philanthropic German playwright Nis-Momme Stockmann. The NZZ listens to the exhilarating and highly complex compositions of Conlon Nancarrow for the mechanical piano. Die Zeit skips Virgil and heads for gluttony level in 'Inferno'.
read more

From the Feuilletons

Saturday 16 - Friday 22 January, 2010

Feuilletonistic debate has become increasingly vicious since the Swiss minaret ban and the attack on Kurt Westergaard. The critics of Islam have been denounced by the Christian heads of Germany's quality feuilletons as "hate preachers" and "holy warriors". "No one is going to stop me from criticising my religion," counters Necla Kelek, one of the three Muslim women and a lone Jewish man who make up the opposition this week.
read more

From the Feuilletons

Saturday 9 - Friday 15 January, 2010

It's not Poland that should westernise, says Polish author Stefan Chwin, but the West which should recognise Poland as one of its own. Philosopher Abdolkarim Soroush explains why Iran's green revolution needs a theory. Writer Peter Shneider is tired of being treated like a minor at the airport. The head of Berlin's Museum of Islamic art explains why, unlike the Met, it will be showing its paintings of Mohammed. And the taz learns that Deleuze could not stomach Wittgenstein, but was partial to brain, tongue and marrow.
read more

From the Feuilletons

Saturday 2 - Friday 8 January 2010

After the attack on Danish cartoonist Kurt Westergaard, the editor of the SZ feuilleton says it's not worth defending something as stupid as his Mohammed cartoons. Henryk Broder, on the other hand, remembers how the media leapt to Rushdie's defence, and paints a picture of creeping capitulation. Arno Widman remembers Albert Camus as the writer who taught us the value of the individual over society, and not the other way around. The head of Surhkamp, Ulla Unseld-Berkewicz, wonders whether quality publishers have any edge at all today. The NZZ traces the highs and lows of pop falsetto.
read more

From the Feuilletons

17 - 28 December, 2009

Boris von Haken's revelation, that the revered musicologist Hans Heinrich Eggebrecht was involved in the murder of 14,000 Jews in Crimea, is a catastrophe for German musicology, says Die Welt. The FAZ asks why Chinese dissident Liu Xiaobo's sentence was kept so quiet. Alexander Kluge celebrates the Net in the spirit of the quantum. And with the Demjanjuk trial underway, the Tagesspiegel remembers the uprising in Sobibor.
read more

From the Feuilletons

Saturday 12 - Friday 18 December, 2009

A rotting plague corpse in wax speaks volumes about contemporary Naples. Die Zeit tells a horrifying story about the former doyen of German musicology Hans-Heinrich Eggebrecht - years after his death he has now been implicated in the murder of 14,000 Jews in Crimea. Oliver Reese's Frankfurt production of "Phaedra" is a celebration of the art of gesture. The Romanian poet Werner Söllner talks about his years as Securitate informer. And, the FR asks, was the Romanian revolution really a revolution after all?
read more

From the Feuilletons

Saturday 5 - Friday 11 December, 2009

The taz bathes in light, in Wolfsburg of all places. Herta Müller explains how literature helps the oppressed. The artist Parastou Forouhar is being kept in Iran against her will. Mircea Cartarescu explains why it is so hard to purge Romania of the Securitate. The poet Durs Grünbein wonders why people feel so aggressive when they see the sculptures of Markus Lüpertz. Navid Kermani says Switzerland has a fundamentalist problem - abut it's not Islamic.
read more

From the Feuilletons

Saturday 28 November - Friday 4 December

The Swiss anti-minaret vote has been the focus of feuilleton attention this week. The NZZ calls it a disgrace for journalism. Tariq Ramadam says the Muslims should have been more active in preventing it. Historian Hamed Abdel-Samad looks at Islam's failure to modernise and says it's time the Muslims engaged in self-criticism if they don't like others doing it. Mario Vargas Llosa praises the EU as the only political project that is both revolutionary and real. And the Tagesschau, Germany's oldest news institution, comes under fire for its stultifying depiction of the world.
read more