The Elbe Philharmonic ? A Musical Challenge

Construction of the Elbe Philharmonic is underway, with its opening planned for autumn, 2011. Hamburg?s creative artists are not alone in seeing a new landmark for their city in this spectacular concert hall.... more more

GoetheInstitute

12/10/2007

From the Feuilletons

From the Feuilletons is a weekly overview of what's been happening in the German-language cultural pages and appears every Friday at 3 pm. CET.. Here a key to the German newspapers.

This week it's books, books, books.

Wednesday saw the opening of the Frankfurt Book Fair, the largest book fair in the world. Hungarian author Peter Zilahy writes in the Frankfurter Allgemeine Zeitung: "Frankfurt is a pilgrimage. Even if you only do it only once in your life, like a Muslim to Mecca." The Neue Zürcher Zeitung agrees, stressing that it's not only writers who think that way: "The mood in the German book trade is great," writes Joachim Güntner. "As festival director Juergen Boos puts it, there's 'a feeling of growth in the air.' The fair is booked out, he says, although one hears conflicting accounts about the presence of Latin American publishers (officially the number is growing, while unofficial sources say it's sinking). The Americans and English, who represent the book fair's 'core markets,' are once again coming in pre 9/11 numbers. Asia is booming in Frankfurt, China has boosted its presence by an impressive thirty percent."

Apparently out of the blue, the FAZ has published two articles in English on the books coming out in Germany this autumn. Both give a good indication FAZ feueillton style. Hubert Spiegel writes on new fiction, and Christian Geyer on new nonfiction.


Rather than inviting a country as guest to the fair, this year Frankfurt features Catalonia as a cultural entity. The decision sparked a huge controversy, as the Barcelona-based Institut Ramon Llull, responsible for the organisation, planned to invite only authors writing in Catalan. Merten Wortmann asks in the Südeutsche Zeitung if the decision doesn't have more to do with politics than with literary quality - to make amends for decades of oppression of Catalan language and literature under Franco. "Long after the dictator's death, writing in Catalan was a sort of unintended political exclamation mark for authors. But this also became a burden, because large sections of the public also automatically assumed that Catalan literature was inextricably linked with the Catalan question, and for that reason saw it as more provincial than it really was. In general, the current generation of writers is considered the first that can 'simply write, without having to defend the fatherland at the same time,' as Barcelona critic Julia Guillamon recently put it. The question remains, she wrote, 'as to whether the Catalan cultural can also survive without a political project.'"


Nuria Amat, a Catalan author who writes in Spanish, wonders in Die Welt whether one hundred years ago it would have been a problem to invite Franz Kafka, who wrote in German, if the Czech Republic had been guest of honour: "Just as we can no longer conceive of Prague without Kafka, we cannot understand Barcelona without its two linguistic cultures. We know that it's the business of politicians to manipulate people with lies, and the business of writers like Kafka to expose lies. But what happens when the politicians and cultural bureaucrats in charge of invitations to Frankfurt refuse an author like Kafka because he's been defined by those handing out the cultural subsidies as an author without a homeland or a language of his own?"


Shortly before the start of the Frankfurt Book Fair, the German Book Prize for 2007 was awarded to Julia Franck for her novel "Die Mittagsfrau" (Lady Midday - excerpt in English here). Writing in Der Tagesspiegel, Gerrit Bartels is anything but thrilled: "Once more, what we have here is a classic jury decision, opting for the book with high target-group appeal. For all its shortcomings, for all its quirky trudging along, for all its insistence on raising the question why Franck is telling us all this in the first place, the book will nonetheless find its audience, and indeed already has. Last week 'Die Mittagsfrau' was ranked at no. 17 on Der Spiegel's bestseller list: A mother leaves her adolescent son alone on a train station at the end of the Second World War and never wants to see him again. There's plenty of people out there who want to know how it got to this. Sad woman supreme, but no 'novel for long discussions,' as the jury has it."

Edo Reents, by contrast, who reviewed the book for the literature section of the FAZ, was deeply impressed. The book "leads us into those eerie human depths about which a political or social statement, that is a value judgement, cannot be uttered," he writes.


And the feuilletons paid considerable attention to Doris Lessing's wining the Nobel Prize for literature. All papers featured lengthy, even full-page articles:

For Jens Balzer in the Berliner Zeitung: "Lessing's opus is broad in reach and genre-bridging but for fifty years it has circled unrelentingly around one and the same question: How to cope in a world where there seem to be no alternatives? What constitutes an indidual's 'own', 'self-determined' life? In our post-emancipatory days many will find such thoughts naive, but this does not make them less true or pressing. The functionaries of old-school literary criticism always viewed Lessing's works with suspicion; no wonder that Germany's most popular literary critic, Marcel Reich Ranicki's spontaneous reaction to the news was 'disappointing.' 'From the Anglo-Saxon world he would have much rather seen John Updike or Philip Roth' take home the award. Like Updike and Roth, Lessing began her career with novels of self-discovery. Not of course with male self-discovery novels but with women's self-discovery novels. She doesn't describe middle-class men agonising over nymphomania and commitment phobia, but middle-class women agonising over commitment and doubts about whether the role of housewife and dutiful mother really is the only one that life has to offer."

Ingeborg Harms in the Frankfurter Allgemeine Zeitung writes: "In her prolific career, Doris Lessing employed intellectual acuity and a necessary dose of sarcasm to create a rich parallel world to the present-obsessed present day. Her books maintain a dialogue with a literary tradition which for centuries formed the yardstick of intellectual life. Doris Lessing is an ambassador of loneliness and she portrays a life in thought as an alternative which becomes ever more plausible as the years go by. Her large heart and her active mind demonstrate how one can write about Afghan refugees and at the same time attend to the fate of female souls with a Jane Austen-like sensibility."

"No, this was not a choice reached using literary criteria alone," writes Lothar Müller in the Süddeutsche Zeitung. "It does not honour a great stylist, nor a writer who developed new narrative forms, such as Coetzee and Imre Kertesz. The Nobel Academy ratified the symbolic importance of a writer at the moment where her work had started to pale. Doris Lessing is a child of the crumbling Commonwealth and a witness of the long process in which Africa began to step out of the colonial shadow. She became a novelist by describing this crumbling and this new begining, in 'The Grass is Singing' for example. But Doris Lessing is also a child of the crumbling of the old order of the sexes, and not only in Europe. She became a world author not only because she described this crumbling and the strengthening of feminism, but because she also demanded it."


Other stories:

Die Zeit 11.10.2007

Jane Fonda turns 70 in December and next week she will be the guest of honour at the Vienna Film Festival. Katja Nicodemus visits the actress and political icon in Atlanta and talks to her across a double page spread. For example about Fonda's attempt to put a feminist spin on the Vietnam film "Coming Home". "I wanted to send out my little message against phallocentrism. The idea was that there should be sex between the paralysed veteran played by Jon Voight and my character, but without penetration. I wanted to show that a man who couldn't get an erection because of his injuries could still be a better lover than the 30-seconds-and its-over man I was married to at the time. So I had to fight it out with director Hal Ashby. I called it the 'great battle of penetration'. One day we had a bunch of veterans on the set as extras in their wheelchairs. One of them had brought his girlfriend along. When I asked him about his sex life he said that he sometimes had erections that lasted four hours. Hal Ashby overheard this and I thought, 'Shit, that's the end of my anti-penetration plan.'"


Die Welt
06.10.2007

Vassili Grossman wrote the "War and Peace" of the 20th century. Historian Karl Schlögel celebrates "Life and Fate", Grossman's epochal novel of the Stalin era, which has just been published in its full 1000-page version in German for the first time. "Grossman follows the trails of his characters at a time when the front wandered Eastwards and ploughed up the entire country, uprooting countless millions of people or burying them in its wake. In Grossman's universe there are German POW camps, concentration camps and the Gulag complexes of Kotlas, Magadan and Kolyma. Grossman knew the milieus which he sketched out with relentless precision, the military jargon, the topics discussed by the intelligentsia in the laboratories that were evacuated to Kasan. It is not just the professional exactitude of the war reporter that fixes the nuances and details in these utterly credible chronicles, but the sharpened perception and presence of mind of the combatant who had learned that a lapse of attention can cost one one's life."


Neue Zürcher Zeitung 06.10.2007

Norwegians are up in arms that boys are doing increasingly poorly at school, while girls' grades are steadily improving, reports Aldo Keel in an article on the latest chapter in the Scandinavian battle of the sexes. Even in maths the girls are on top, he writes. In Norwegian, moreover, girls now have "twice as many top marks as boys, once the stronger sex. Instead of delighting in the girls' successes, teachers are issuing a sorry lament. School is too theory-heavy for the boys, they say, and too much time is spent sitting still. Schools favour discipline, diligence, exactitude and a sense of responsibility, all considered 'female values'. 'School is too feminine,' the left-socialist education minister recently announced. 'We've got to create a more masculine arena.' His proposal: 'More action. More computers.'"

Get the signandsight newsletter for regular updates on feature articles.
signandsight.com - let's talk european.

 
More articles

From the Feuilletons

Saturday 4 - Friday 10 October

Reactions to JMG Le Clezio's Nobel Prize are at best lukewarm. An anonymous banker discusses the personal advantages of his job. Ralf Dahrendorf refuses to bitch about the Americans. The point is not whether women in Turkey should wear the headscarf, says Necla Kelek, but where they can go without it. La Traviata has been transformed on Platform 9 in Zurich's central station. And now for a blasphemous question: Was Beuys an "eternal Hitler youth"?
read more

From the Feuilletons

Thursday 2 October, 2008

The SZ celebrates a scattering of doppelgängers in a new production of Kafka's "Trial". It also ogles a philosophical diable de l'amour on Arte. In die Welt, Peter Weibel debunks the cult of the artist. The Berliner Zeitung marvels at the riches of Omsk. The NZZ fumes at the arrogance of Horace Engdahl and revisits the cleavage of Madame de Stael.
read more

From the Feuilletons

Friday 26 September 2008

Actor Moritz Bleibtreu tells how playing RAF terrorist Andreas Baader like he was could only result in comedy. Simon Rattle, Daniel Harding and Michael Boder have conducted Karlheinz Stockhausen's "Groups for Three Orchestras" like a flight in a helicopter. Bulgarian author Georgi Gospodinov explains why Berlin's urinals are different from Bulgaria's. And Uwe Tellkamp's thousand page novel "Der Turm" about a small GDR elite has hit reviewers like a bombshell.
read more

From the Feuilletons

Friday 19 September, 2008

The FR castigates the Germans for being so nuts about Obama when they've never elected so much as a Turkish mayor. Author and entrepeneur, Ernst-Wilhelm Händler, declares that it's not capitalism that has failed but the state. Andrzej Stasiuk spent his holidays in the Russian steppes where unlimited space felt penal. The NZZ sings a swan song for German theatre's Utopian dreams and the SZ bids farewell to the man who put the fun back into New Music.
read more

From the Feuilletons

Friday 12 September, 2008

Ukrainian author Oksana Zabuzhko remembers the mass grave in the forest of Bykivnya, where the bodies are inscribed with "the Russian signature". Marcia Pally lists a string of dirty wars waged by the Democrats. The SZ praises "Gomorrah" the Mafia film with no Godfatherly glamour. Georgian writer Dato Barbakadze tells Russian intellectuals to raise their voices in protest. And the Tagesspiegel celebrates the very un-McKinseyan ethos of Cern.
read more

From the Feuilletons

Friday 5 September, 2008

Jungle World investigates academic anti-Semitism and Jewish self-hatred with Theodor Lessing. It also looks at Gaussian distribution as an instrument of suppression. Christoph Schlingensief talks about his stay in the first station of hell. The feuilletons are relieved to finally close the chapter on the Bayreuth war of succession. And Andreas Dresen's film "Cloud 9" ushers in the grey phase of the sexual revolution.
read more

From the Feuilletons

Saturday 23 - Friday 29 August, 2008

Sitting in Moscow traffic, Sonja Margolina learns a tough lesson about life in Russian civil society. The Tagesspiegel dismisses the second volume of Günter Grass's autobiography, "The Box", as an orgy of vagueness. Christoph Schlingensief remembers how Wolfgang Wagner stole his urinal. And Die Zeit fears for the youth of today, who have had the protest scared out of them.
read more

From the Feuilletons

Saturday 16 - Friday 22 August, 2008

Did Carl Philipp Emmanuel hide the end of the 'Art of Fugue'? Organist Ton Koopman casts aspersions on Bach's son. Michel Houellebecq explains why the problem is genital. Diedrich Diederichsen remembers meeting a certain New York waitress back in '82. Ukrainian writer Yuri Andrukhovych explains why he's on Georgia's side. Osssetian literature academic Shanna Chochiyeva explains why she thinks the Georgians are Nazis. And Czech playright Pavel Kohout says what the Russians need is another revolution.
read more

From the Feuilletons

Friday 9-15 August, 2008

Georgian author Devi Dumbadze criticises the powerless nationalism of his compatriots. Andre Glucksman and Bernard-Henri Levy diagnose Europe in a coma. A new book by Patrick Buisson describes the erotic confusion that gripped Vichy France. Syrian philospher Sadik Jalal al-Azm points to a third way for Islam. The SZ takes a magical history tour of YouTube piano recitals. And old Austrian men in lederhosen take to the streets in protest against Kippenberger's crucified frog.
read more

From the Feuilletons

Saturday 26 July - Friday 1 August, 2008

This year's 'Parsifal' in Bayreuth is a romp through German history. Twenty years after the fall of the Wall, Ingo Schulze says the West has made less than minimal progress. A group of intellectuals take up Pascal Bruckner's appeal to "Boycott Durban 2". Anselm Kiefer reveals all about his Virgin Mary visitation. Necla Kelek is deeply suspicious of Tariq Ramadan's campaign against forced marriage. And Carlos Fraenkel is wowed by the hermeneutic flexibility of Indonesian Muslims.
read more

From the Feuilletons

Saturday 19 - Friday 25 July, 2008

Karadzic's successful hiding methods prompt the SZ to draw up a set of rules for war criminals living underground: rise early and travel to work by bus or train. The Bosnian writer Dzevad Karahasan remembers the thousands of lesser war criminals who are still living in impunity. Theatre director Ariane Mnouchkin has produced a number of short protest films against the Olympic Games in Bejing. And Berlin is still recovering from a breathless weekend of Obamarama.
read more

From the Feuilletons

Saturday 12 - Friday 18 July, 2008

Romanian-German writer Herta Müller protests against the participation of former Securitate informants in the Berlin Summer Academy. Richard Wagner seconds her objections. South African writer Andre Brink explains why he remains loyal to his homeland. Spanish poet Marcos Ana remembers how he smuggled his first poem out of prison in a tube of toothpaste. Sociologist Gerhard Schulze examines the very real fears about nursing homes. And Algerian author Boualem Sansal egotistically pins his hopes on the democratising forces of the Mediterranean Union.
read more

From the Feuilletons

Saturday 4 - Friday 11 July, 2008

German President Horst Köhler managed to be out of the room, when the Tibet question was raised. Author and Iranian regime critic Said explains why he was prevented from giving a reading in Berlin together with an Israeli colleague. The Russian cultural minister announces that the state will be commissioning major feature films to further the cause of patriotism. Mongolian shaman and author Galsan Tschinag reports on post-election protests in Ulan Bator. And Die Zeit portrays Chinese environmental activist Wu Lihong, who is sitting out a prison sentence.
read more

From the Feuilletons

Saturday 28 June - Friday 4th July

Moscow curator Andrei Erofeyev has lost his job because of the negative effects of art on the mind. The SZ welcomes Fethullah Gülen as the world's top public intellectual and merrily waves goodbye to the Enlightenment in the process. Die Welt reads a black book of the French Revolution. Die Presse explains what the United Nations Human Rights Council understands by "abuse of freedom of expression". On Kafka's 125th birthday, the feuilletons heap praise on the second volume of Reiner Stach's biography. And Jonathan Franzen explains what he loves about Berlin: it's a shadow of its former self.
read more

From the Feuilletons

Saturday 21 - Friday 27 June, 2008

Olivier Roy locates the roots of Islamic radicalisation in the West not the Koran. Slavenka Drakulic comments on the UN's decision to classify rape as a war crime. Peter Handke's love of Serbia is obscene says Jonathan Littell. Günther Verheugen and Jürgen Habermas argue about the Irish "no". Habermas meets Tariq Ramadan in Schloss Elmau. Writer and translator Georges-Arthur Goldschmidt slams the Parisian "Pleiade" publishers for including Ernst Jünger in their library of classics but not Thomas Mann.
read more