Physical Dramaturgy: Ein (neuer) Trend?

Dramaturgie im zeitgenössischen Tanz ist ? positiv gemeint ? ein heißes Eisen. Idealerweise sind Dramaturginnen und Dramaturgen während der Erarbeitung eines Stücks die besten Freunde der Choreografen. more more



The barb of variety

Josef H. Reichholf's book on the origin of beauty is a declaration of love for a nature that is not simply utilitarian but also wasteful and theatrical. By Horst Bredekamp

Well-meaning critics struggled to conceal their perplexity, behind which laid a thick wall of denial. The second part of "Descent of Man" published in 1871 contained Charles Darwin's treatise on "sexual selection", which presented perhaps his greatest failure. Darwin was confronted with the problem of not believing that nature, which was literally exploding with variety and diversity, could be explained solely with the aid of "natural selection". To resolve this conflict he came up with the theory of "sexual" selection, making the female eye the agent of evolution. "Female choice" as he called it, was in no only way solely obligated to follow a commitment to strength and guaranteed survival; the female interest essentially followed another principle, one that could be described as the desire for variation. This meant that Darwin was defining nature, to a certain extent, as a history of erotic form – or even art. In regarding the bodies of animals as self-produced images, he defined his second pillar of evolution as an astonishing pictorial theatre which arose out of the interplay of the female eye in the search for variation and the readiness of the male to mutate.

The Origin of Beauty: Darwin's greatest Dilemma.
By Josef H. Reichholf. (C.H.Beck Verlag)

Fellow naturalists like Alfred R. Wallace were so dismissive of Darwin's theory because they could not accept the existence of a variational drive independent of the pressure to conform to the environment.

Evolutionary biology has never managed to shake off this discomfort, even if the theory of sexual selection continues to be picked up by outsiders and has been cautiously integrated into and developed by the mainstream. The misgivings were also culturally determined. Unlike Darwin's 1859 treatise "The Origin of Species by Means of Natural Selection, or the Preservation of Favoured Races in the Struggle for Life" which hit a nerve at a time when the struggle for survival was being unleashed under the conditions of burgeoning capitalism, his concept of sexual selection inadvertently struck at the neurotic core of the Victorian obsession with controlling drives. This provoked a resistance whose unacknowledged psychological roots made it virtually invincible.

The ambitious venture by the Munich evolutionary biologist Josef H. Reichholf ignores such quarrels of scientific history because Darwin's basic idea strikes him as self-evident. He does not seek to justify it so much as solve the problems it poses. His book presents a formidable abundance of insights, which the author formulates in the most poignant language as the fundamental questions of evolutionary biology.

The theory of sexual selection relies on the category of beauty. Until now, the most comprehensive presentations of this concept in the work of Charles Darwin have come from literary scholars like George Levine and Winfried Menninghaus. Reichholf acknowledges their work but promises to get to the heart of Darwin's problem in the natural world. Aware that the search for the "matter itself" is the product of a theoretical decision, the author regularly punctuates his lists of examples with reflections on the legitimacy of his approach and the fundamental questions that arise from it.

The book excels in the passages where, during the discussion of existing knowledge, the author suddenly leaps to his own observations about the courtship behaviour of the Black Grouse or the texture of feathers. Here his writing takes on a quality that touches the most brilliant passages of Darwin's own. At the end of his "Origin of Species" where he describes an "untangled bank", Darwin talked about beauty in such soulful terms that he acquired the status of a talented novelist, and in several chapters of "Sexual Selection" this adulatory enthusiasm for nature's creations as works of art shines through.

In his extensive discussion of the world of birds, Reichholf begins with Darwin's paragons, the peacock and the Great Argus. The regularity of his encounters with the unexpected prompts him to ask whether there might be some order in diversity. But, he notes, it is difficult to find plausible answers to such a question when the human perception of colour alone differs from that of the animals in question. Moreover, abundance, diversity and excess not only exhaust themselves in the development of species' form and colour but also in the richness of the variety and individuality of voices and songs. These too can only be classed outside the sphere of pure necessity.

The author's central example is the stag and the interplay between the unique antler forms and their beguiling acoustics. For the hinds it is not, as one might expect, the most aggressive males that are attractive. So-called killer stags which murder their opponents are spurned, whereas the males with antlers resembling the crown of a tree and which have deep belling voices have far greater chances of being accepted by a female. The elucidation of the courtship rituals of deer is just one of the sections of the book in which the author passionately pursues a display of splendour as unfolding over countless generations.

Biologists will probably be most impressed by Reichholf's dismissal of the so-called handicap theory, which holds that the extraordinary extravagance of, say, the peacock's plumage is evidence that its owner can afford such luxury impairments in the struggle for survival due to superior power and health. In a series of cases Reichholf demonstrates that beauty can certainly indicate health, which is presented to the female as a sign of honesty. Beauty in such cases is associated with an expression of reliability that demonstrates the ability to sire strong offspring and provide for the young.

In contrast to this restrained confirmation, however, comes a rebuttal of the handicap theory that divides into two extremes. First Reichholf points out that what might appear to be a handicap can be absolutely functional, and in doing so he also contradicts Darwin. He explains, for example, that the peacock's vast plumage makes for excellent protection, functioning as a buffer in an attack and, moreover, that it can be shed instantaneously if the bird needs to flee. Which leaves the theory about the peacock's tail as a theatrically staged luxury weakness in tatters.

Reichholf's decisive rejection of the handicap theory however begins at the most diametrically opposed point, with the conviction that beauty emerges in a sort of self-propelled release of excess vital energy. An experiment in which zebra finches were fitted with coloured rings on their legs resulted in a significant preference for these conspecifics and demonstrated the triumph of variety over all other criteria. From this and other observations the author deduces that it is not necessarily external circumstances that lead to variational-based mating and thus the evolutionary impetus, but far more the possible forms of internal development.

For Reichholf however this means it is not enough to describe evolution as an interplay of external influences and inner reaction. In adaptation he says, the more powerful force is the kaleidoscope of possibilities which relativises all mechanics of necessity. In essence his redefining of sexual selection is a reflection on the degrees of freedom in evolution. The more complex organisms become, the more they liberate themselves from external living conditions and allow the attraction of beauty to play out its anarchic game.

With this conclusion the author, together with the poet Miki Sakamoto, addresses something that also defines human behaviour. Here, too, the definition of beauty is affected. In Reichholf's opinion this cannot be reduced to measureable symmetry and a healthy appearance; more important is the added tension of variation on the expected average specimen. The ideal images of what is regarded as human beauty appear pleasant but are bland and only minimally attractive because their symmetry lacks the barb of variety. Even for Darwin this provided the only possibility of defining beauty. He defined it as variety. According to this definition, forms that appear ugly can also achieve the category of beauty as long as they are recognised as variation. This alone allows us to see evolution as the search of the female eye for variety.

In this context it is regrettable that the author was not able to include a series of profound art and cultural historical discussions of the problem: "Endless forms" (Cambridge and New Haven 2009), "Darwin. Kunst und die Suche nach den Ursprüngen" [Darwin. Art and the search for origins] (Frankfurt am Main 2009) and "Was ist schön?" [What is beautiful?] (Dresden 2010). In the catalogue of the exhibition in Dresden's Hygiene Museum, Menninghaus drew a direct link between Darwin's predilection for the question of ornamentation and the British love of ornament and its art historical formulation. If Mario Praz, one could conclude, could explain English dark romanticism as a revenant of a buried world of images, then Darwin's concept of sexual selection is like a transferral of this impulse onto nature. Darwin's concept of sexual selection can be understood against this background also as a natural variant of the return of suppressed Catholic imagery. These references suggest a conceptual framework in which Darwin developed his second key idea. This does not relativise this concept but defines the form of possibility of his own cultural environment.

Conceptually then it would have been helpful if the author had ascribed the phrase "survival of the fittest" that was so appalling under Social Darwinism not to Darwin himself, but to Herbert Spencer. Then he could have done away with a prejudice, especially as Darwin himself, when explaining the principle of sexual selection sighed: "Too much (...) survival of the fittest. "In view of the wealth of material and aspects covered in the book it is unavoidable that peer reviewers will point out omissions and weak points in the details. For example, it is hard to comprehend why the two-volume collection "Bird Coloration" from 2006 (here and here) was not included. But complaints of this kind do not affect the substance of the book. In times of large-scale molecular biological studies the reader senses that the book wants to remind us about the sort of research that studies living beings in their natural or artificially formed environments and also holds them in deep admiration. In this respect the book is also a declaration of love for a nature that is not only utilitarian but also wasteful, which does not simply fulfill expectations, but exaggerates and in which the theatrical is just as valid as the mechanics of natural selection. In essence, this is a book about freedom. Seldom has evolution been described on this level not as the realm of hard necessity, but as an abundance of possible forms.

The author draws his conclusions from the immediate observation of nature and yet arrives at opinions which in their implications have a clear, critical contemporary reference. His book defends altruism, an all-too precarious commodity these days, in the question of why deer antlers have developed in such a way that they are unable to inflict overly drastic wounds on opponents. It also recognises a sort of compensatory justice in the fact that males have better survival chances but that females, for their part, have the privilege of choice. Ultimately he defines the category of freedom as the product of the search for beauty occurring in nature as an evolutionary process itself.

For Reichholf the principle of sexual selection promotes altruism, justice and freedom. Darwin sometimes described nature as the great "slaughterhouse" but his theory of sexual selection put forth an image of productive wastefulness. Anyone who believes that Darwin's second theory is too beautiful to be true will find themselves on shakier ground after reading this book.


Horst Bredekamp is professor of Art History at the University of Humboldt-University of Berlin and a permanent fellow of the Wissenschaftskolleg in Berlin. He is the author of numerous books on art history, including the highly acclaimed "The Lure of Antiquity and the Cult of the Machine".

Josef H. Reichholf was born in 1945 in Aigen am Inn. A zoologist, evolutionary biologist and ecologist he is a professor of Conservation at the Technical University, Munich. Reicholf is also a presidium member of the German WWF and has received, among others, the Sigmund Freud prize for scientific prose.

This article was originally published in the Süddeutsche Zeitung on 2 May, 2011

Translation: lp

Get the signandsight newsletter for regular updates on feature articles. - let's talk european.

More articles

From pasta to pyrotechnics

Monday 25 July, 2011

We should be playing more and working less, according to philosopher and author Byung-Chul Han. He argues from the standpoint of Asian thinking yet is firmly rooted in the Western tradition. Ronald Düker visits Byung-Chul Han at the University of Arts and Design in Karlsruhe to find out how to make our minds more supple.
read more

The Freudian romance

Thursday 9 June 2011

TeaserPicSelf-analysis and great romantic literature: Sigmund Freud was separated from his bride Martha Bernays for four years. Almost entirely kept under lock and key until the early 2000s, the first volume of their correspondence, the approximately 1,500 letters of the so-called "bridal letters" has now just been published for the first time. The first of five planned volumes is discussed by Jean Bollack.
read more

Save Benjamin from his fans!

Monday 11 October, 2010

TeaserPicWalter Benjamin took his life seventy years ago. Today the cult of Benjamin has turned him into kitsch and his almost entirely false theories into intellectual blancmange. Author Stephan Wackwitz picks apart the legend of a saint whose work should be read as Romantic literature.

read more

Chalk and the abyss

Wednesday May 19, 2010

As rector of the Albert Ludwig University in the winter of 1933/34, Martin Heidegger gave a seminar which was said to contain decisive evidence of the total identification of his teachings with the principles of Hitlerism. Now, thanks to his son Hermann Heidegger, the secret transcripts of this seminar "On the Essence and Concepts of Nature, History and the State" have been published for the first time. By Alexander Kissler
read more

The attack of the 13th fairy

Wednesday 9 February, 2010

Filmmaker and writer Alexander Kluge is no optimist, but he knows ways out of the present. Freitag magazine engages him in a conversation about the World Wide Web, dragonflies, the belief in better human beings and why he likes "gardener" as a job description.
read more

The origin of the world

Thursday 18 June, 2009

TeaserPicMithu M. Sanyal, a self-proclaimed "provocative feminist", has written a cultural history of the vulva. Richly illustrated and packed with knowledgeable synopses, it has directed the media spotlight into a symbolic and semantic void. By Ulrike Baureithel
read more

Good readers are cannibals

Monday 15 December, 2008

TeaserPicKurt Flasch's book "Kampfplätze der Philosophie" strides across the battlefields of philosophy from Augustine to Voltaire. After a weekend spent scribbling furiously in its margins, Arno Widmann was enlightened, exhilarated and hungry for more.
read more

Mohammed on the "straight path"

Tuesday 8 April, 2008

Did the Prophet Mohammed only become a power-conscious religious politician in Medina, where he emigrated from Mecca in 622? Author of a new Mohammed biography, Tilman Nagel has found much to indicate the absence of any genuine break in the evolution of this religious founder.

read more

A new cosmopolitanism is in the air

Wednesday 21 November, 2007

The global power of capital has no need for military force. And it is nigh on boundless. Sociologist Ulrich Beck presents seven theses for a better world.
read more

Banished to the banlieues

Wednesday 14 November, 2007

The Parisian social sciences institutes are being turfed out of their ancestral homes in the city's most desirable arrondissements and relocated to Aubervilliers. A bitter pill, but also a chance to turn theory into practice. By Wolf Lepenies
read more

Children of the sun

Wednesday 12 September, 2007

All light-generating substances, as well as the oxygen they consume, stem ultimately from trapped solar energy. The pulsing points of light in the depths of our oceans are distant offspring of the sunlight. Biochemist Gottfried Schatz follows light across time and space, from the Big Bang to the ocean floor.

read more

"The time for philosophising is over"

Monday 20 August, 2007

Ernst Tugendhat, philosopher and critic of German pseudo-profundity, talks to Ulrike Herrmann about the fear of death, Heidegger, anti-Semitism and unfounded speculations in brain research.

read more

Dumber in English

Thursday July 12, 2007

Is German academic language dying in the face of the dominant Anglo-Saxon? Well, revive it! Biophysicist and author Stefan Klein doesn't think German scholars should try to impress the world with mediocre English. He makes a case for the mother tongue, proposing incentives such as prizes for the best scientific texts. After all, everyone craves rewards.

read more

Philosopher, poet and friend

Tuesday 12 June, 2007

The American thinker Richard Rorty passed away on Friday at his home in California. German philosopher Jürgen Habermas tells what makes Rorty unique among intellectuals, and what binds Rorty, orchids, and justice on earth.

read more