The Ideology-Critical Method of Immanent Critique

In the scholarly disciplines, the criticism of ideology is hardly spoken of any longer. The ideology-critical method of immanent critique, associated with the philosopher Karl Marx, is frowned upon. Wrongly. It is a philosophical method that goes back to Socrates and that has since been developed further.... more more

GoetheInstitute

05/11/2007

The universal spirit takes a walk

Gustav Seibt pays tribute to Thuringia and Saxony Anhalt, Germany's neglected cultural heartland

Prussia is undergoing its periodic revival in historical memory. Spawned by a 200-year anniversary of its defeats and reforms, fired by brilliant portraits such as Christopher Clark's "Prussia" (more) or Günter de Bruyn's "Als Poesie gut", both of which made the bestseller lists, the public has discovered a state that was concerned with matters of the mind and spirit a far cry from militarism. The intellectual nostalgia for Humboldt and the undiminished relevance of Schinkel's functionalism haven't hurt either.

Equally relevant is that, a decade after the German capital moved to Berlin, the new arrivals have begun exploring their surroundings and are setting themselves up in the old manor houses and farms, next to the simple churches with their graveyards full of soldiers and poets. Fontane will become, for a new generation, the local historical guide to all things Prussian and everyone is just waiting for the new edition of Willibald Alexis' "Die Hosen des Herrn von Bredow," (Herr von Bredow's trousers) which never fell from grace, not even in the GDR.

But however attractive the steppes-like landscape between Beeskow and Angermünde, however tasty the organic fruit from Brodowin and charming the manor houses around Großziethen, it is primarily the quietness and emptiness that appeals to R&R hungry Berliners eager to swap the city's excesses for a weekend spent savouring a little officer's anecdote about a count who, for a change, chose to disobey the king and had inscribed on his grave: "Chose disgrace when obedience would have caused him dishonour."

If you drive two hundred kilometers south, you come to a region where a lot more was going on. Here the history is so intricate and divided that it can't be made to suit the purposes of nostalgic identification although this is where, quite literally, everything German that had a positive influence on the world, began. Between Wittenberg on the Elbe and Weimar on the Ilm are regions that get hillier to the south, in whose little cities creative production developed over three centuries with an intensity comparable only to Tuscany in the Renaissance or Greece in Antiquity. Thuringia and what used to be the regions of Anhalt are to the Germany what Umbria is to the Italians: the heart of our country. But this never acknowledged by those caught up praising Prussia.

Yet a simple listing of events reveals this to be an anomaly. This region – between Erfurt and Wittenberg – is where Luther's Reformation began, and spread around the world, making among other things, the United States what it is today. Here - between Weimar and Dessau – the Bauhaus style was developed, and continues to shape metropolises the world over. And here Bach and Goethe got to work, here Luther wrote his translation of the Bible in the German language we still write with today.

When Goethe held his eulogy for Christoph Martin Wieland in 1813, he said – referring to the battle of Jena and Auerstedt – world history has decided "to accompany us on our walks." This is yet more applicable in a spiritual sense. When Napoleon rode from Jena to Weimar in 1806, the "Phenomenology of Spirit" lay on a desk in one city, the first part of "Faust" in the other. Yet the region was not under the rule of some splendid state power but rather shared between a puzzle of principalities which anywhere elsewould have been considered little more than estates.

There was a prince on the Elbe who converted his entire property into a landscape garden and who preferred to mark all the final exams in his schools personally. The University of Jena, which four patrons had struggled to keep on its legs, became home to a revolution in the history of philosophy. The Duke of Weimar had his best poet design the interior of his castle. During the summer in a little nest called Lauchstädt, plays that would have been more at home in the "Comedie francaise" were put on before audiences of 500, featuring a cast of mostly students from Halle, while the absent theatre director, Herr von Goethe, had his partner inform him of the nightly hauls – between 350 thalers (for Schiller) and 250 (for Goethe).

It's worth taking a trip to Lauchstädt to see the virtually un-changed theatre that Goethe designed himself, right down to the colour scheme, to gauge the incredible discrepancy between the puppet-like surroundings and the spiritual heights. The universal spirit really was taking walks here and most of them ended in the same spot. In Ilmenau, in Ossmannstedt or Bad Berka – there was hardly a place that did not spawn a classical work.

What made such productivity possible? I could spin all sorts of grand theories – such as the one about the situation in a former colonial country where things that had been developed elsewhere were simplified or crystallised and tailored for export: the German language, for example, which Luther trimmed of its dialect for interregional use; or Christianity, which the very same Luther freed of its swarm of saints and religious prescriptions; or functional building practice, which manifested itself in the classicism of Wörlitz and in Bauhaus, where beauty met praticality and affordability.

More tangible perhaps was situtation arising from the smallness of the courts. This offered protection against the outside world and internal material constraints which combined to promote stubbornness and ingenuity. Without his Saxon princes, Luther would have been just another burned heretic of the late Middle Ages. And the representational needs of a dozen courts concentrated in a small area gave rise to a vast handicraft tradition and the aesthetic education of an entire region – but with the most modest means. Culture between Wörlitz and Weimar consisted largely of plaster, papier mache and local building materials, the charm had to come from the conception, the brilliant idea. The unmistakable certainty in taste, décor included, bears witness to the breadth of this aesthetic understanding.

It was similar with music, which, rather than working with the large apparatuses of the opera and courtly representation, remained within the domain of church and chamber music. The countryside that boasted a castle every fifty kilometers didn't produce a Versailles, and all that goes along with it, not even a Potsdam, but works that could be performed for the church pews or on a few planks: the "Matthäuspassion" and the "Torquato Tasso." Luther's Bible was completed in a tower and then interpreted by hundreds of students. The unique burst of productivity in central Germany stems from this intimacy.

It never meant provincialism. Court culture at any level is, by definition, internationally-networked, if only for marital reasons. The princes and princesses of Anhalt and Saxony-Coburg ended up on the thrones of Russia and England, Belgium and Bulgaria and several smaller countries.

This is the inheritance of Germany and by extension, of two of its poorer federal states - Saxony Anhalt and Thuringia. Which is why it is so problematic that we have an elegant, urban nostalgia for Prussia but no real awareness of the core zone between the Elbe and the Thuringian forest. Dresden was an asset to national efforts, aided by the TV broadcasters, but in Weimar, a library burnt to the ground because there was no funding for interim storage.

The Foundation of Weimar Classics is doing reasonably well under the circumstances. The gardens in Wörlitz are grotesquely under-funded and in Thuringia, you need only to leave Weimar for Gotha, let's say, to find unimaginable neglect. In Gotha there's a castle which dates back to 1643 and represents the first building of distinction to be erected in the aftermath of the Thirty Years War: historically a place of unique interest with heavy, bulging Italian stucco, – the first suggestion of aesthetic global traffic. But who has heard of Gotha? Nobody reads Gustav Freytag's novel "The Lost Manuscript" anymore, which is set in the castle, and the social democrats, who released their most important agenda there, have greater worries than the upkeep of tradition. Fifty years ago, when Thomas Mann was driving to Weimar via Gotha, he stopped at Freytag's grave, in the suburb of Siebleben, to commemorate his once-famous colleague.

Thuringia and Anhalt have disappeared from the public eye because they don't have a Berlin at their centre, from where curious city folk, armed with literature, can set off for their villages and royal estates. But they are the most cultivated and historically interesting parts of Germany and they don't have a Fontane, quite simply because they have so much more to tell.

*

This article originally appeared in the Süddeutsche Zeitung on Thursday 6 September, 2007.


Gustav Seibt, born in 1959, studied literature and history. He was editor at the Frankfurter Allgemeine Zeitung, has written for Die Zeit and currently writes for the Süddeutsche Zeitung. His most recent book "Rom oder Tod" deals with the founding of Italy in 1861.

translation: nb


Get the signandsight newsletter for regular updates on feature articles.

 
More articles

Evil and the upright citizen

Monday 4 February, 2008

A large-scale and long-overdue project has begun. German historians are documenting the persecution and extermination of the Jews in 16 volumes of primary source texts where metal merchants and budgie lovers all have their say - with no recourse to hindsight. By Eckhard Fuhr
read more

Waking a Polish demon

Monday 21 January, 2008

"Fear" is the punchy title of book about Polish anti-Semitism whose recent publication in Poland has sparked an emotional debate. Very few people have come to the defence of its author, Jan Tomasz Gross, who has taken on the difficult task of making uncomfortable facts known to a wider audience and removing blind spots in Polish history. By Jakub Kloc-Konkolowicz
read more

Back to Rudi Dutschke's pram

Monday 7 January, 2008

So what was 1968? It was when the children of German mass murderers ran after mass murderer Mao Tsedong, says historian and ex-Maoist Götz Aly. Absolutely not, says educationalist and author Katharina Rutschky: The practice of dispelling fascism in the kindergarten was far more important than ideology. Stefan Reinecke and Jan Feddersen preside over a full-blown row.
read more

Good comrades

Monday 29 October, 2007

Last week the 1945 Rechnitz massacre hit the headlines after British journalist David Litchfield maintained that Countess Margit von Batthyany, partial heir to the Thyssen industrial family, had taken part in the atrocity. But such speculations belong to the boulevard press. The real issue is the scandalous role of the German postwar criminal justice system in letting the perpetrators escape Germany unharmed. By Stefan Klemp
read more

Under the sign of half truth

Monday 10 September, 2007

The dawn of a new era in Central Eastern Europe means confronting the legacy of communism and fascism. While there is no lack of advice and admonition from Western Europe, or coarse dressing-downs from Moscow, these nations must be given the time they need to unravel their complicated history. Romanian-German writer Richard Wagner guides us through some of the thorniest issues. (Photo © Lothar Deus)

read more

"Being high, being free, terrorism's gotta be"

Thursday 6 September, 2007

Thirty years ago, the kidnapping of German industrialist Hanns Martin Schleyer by the Red Army Faction signalled the beginning of the Deutscher Herbst, the highpoint of German terrorism. Arno Widmann looks back on the culture of violence in the 1970s.
read more

Shooting down the system

Wednesday 22 August, 2007

A document recently made public testifies that the secret police of the GDR were instructed to shoot anyone attempting to escape over the border to West Germany. While the fact is already widely known, the publication has unleashed a new debate about the shootings at the wall. East German author Reinhard Jirgl explains why. (Image © Peter-Andreas Hassiepen)
read more

The distance of victims

Thursday August 9, 2007

Raul Hilberg, the father of Holocaust research, died on August 5th. The sobriety of tone and relentness precision with which he exposed the administrative machine behind what he termed "The Destruction of the European Jews" contributed to the book's failure to receive recognition for decades. His portrayal of facelessness spells out a chilling lesson for the future. By Gustav Seibt
read more

Crying Nazi

Thursday 5 July, 2007

So Martin Walser, Siegfried Lenz and Dieter Hildebrandt are Nazis now. Oh please! Ever more intellectuals who have spent a lifetime fighting for left-liberal causes are being outed as party members. By Franziska Augstein
read more

The double Prussia

Wednesday 16 May, 2007

Brilliantly narrated, justly arbitrated: historian Christopher Clark has written a masterpiece on the Hohenzollern state of Prussia. By Volker Ullrich
read more

Historicising the historians

Monday 8 January, 2006

Historian Norbert Frei invited specialists of the National Socialist era to Jena for a kind of family reunion. At debate was the history of the historians of National Socialism and the question of when, and if, the notion of objectivity begins to apply. By Stefan Reinecke
read more

The Years of Extermination

Monday 23 October, 2006

Some people will think: "Not another book on the Holocaust!" But historian Saul Friedländer depicts the "Years of Extermination" with tremendous power and drama. His narrative style is much like that of a film director, elegantly combining individual stories with world events. By Dan Diner
read more

An ungainly treasure chest

Wednesday 23 August, 2006

The new permanent exhibition at the German Historical Museum has reopened in Berlin's Zeughaus. Historian Christoph Jahr says the show is too soft on the GDR, makes unreflective use of both communist and Nazi lingo and is overly rooted in the idea of the nation-state. Lots to say, but little substance. (Image: Bernhard Stigel: Kaiser Maximilian I, 1496)
read more

The logic of horror

Monday 12 June, 2006

20 years after the "Historikerstreit" there is a new lesson to learn in contemporary history: the repugnant aspects of the twentieth century can not be reduced to the major totalitarian dictatorships and they can not be cleanly distinguished from all that we now view as progress and success. By Götz Aly
read more